30 Nov 2017 • Preprocessor madness 2

More preprocessor craziness:

#define A 1
// do not define B
#if A == B
int main() { return 0; }

Shows no warnings with -Wall -Wextra, you have to go -Weverything to get -Wundef to get "warning: "B" is not defined, evaluates to 0".

This doesn't seem like a big deal but we got bit by it. A colleague renamed the OSX platform define to MACOS, then presuambly he went down all the compile errors and fixed them. Unfortunately we had something like:

#include "windows_semaphore.h"
#elif OSX
#include "osx_semaphore.h"
#include "posix_semaphore.h"

which doesn't throw any errors if you change the define to MACOS because OSX defines the POSIX semaphore interface. It is broken though, because all the sem_ functions return "not implemented" errors at runtime!

It's very frustrating that the most basic building blocks we have in programming are full of shitty shit like this. I have no suggestions on how to improve things or any interesting commentary to add beyond that.